Sell your cards to us.
If you have Magic: The Gathering cards sitting in a closet, garage, attic, or storage unit, we are buyers.
We especially want collections from the 1990s and early 2000s, Reserved List singles, sealed product, and estate lots. We pay 70–80% of market on Reserved List and vintage singles, where most buylists pay about half.
Send a list, photos, or just a description of what you have. We usually reply within 1–2 business days, and the offer costs you nothing.
Prefer email? Write to info@moxmulligan.com, or message us on any of these:
Get an offer
Tell us what you have. Card names and rough counts are enough to start.
What we pay
The exact percentage depends on condition, demand, and how quickly the card is likely to sell. Reserved List and vintage cards land at the top of these ranges, and modern Standard reprints at the bottom.
| What you have | Our offer |
|---|---|
| Reserved List and vintage singlesMana Vault, Vampiric Tutor, dual lands, Argothian Enchantress | 70–80% |
| Modern-era rares and mythicsModern format staples, Commander chase rares, recent-set mythics | 55–70% |
| Sealed productBooster boxes, Collector Boosters, Commander decks, bundles | 75–85% |
| Bulk rares ($1–5 each)Older sets, off-meta rares, foils with light play wear | $0.10–0.25 each |
| Bulk commons and uncommonsSorted or unsorted boxes | $5 per 1,000 |
Percentages are of TCG Mid Price, the median market price on TCGplayer on the day we make the offer. We do not use stale prices.
How it works
- Send a list or photos Email or message us with your cards. A spreadsheet is ideal but not required. Set names and rough counts are enough to start. For cards worth more than about $25, photos help. We will tell you within a day whether the collection is something we buy.
- Get an offer in 1–2 business days We price every card against the current TCGplayer market and apply our offer percentage. You get an itemized offer, card by card, not one number for the whole lot. You see what each card is worth and what we are paying for it.
- Ship the cards or hand them off We send a prepaid USPS Priority label for collections over $200. In the Oklahoma City metro we can meet in person for a collection of any size. We pay the same day the cards arrive, by Zelle, PayPal Goods & Services, or check.
What we buy
We are a small shop, not a wholesaler. We are picky about what we buy because we are picky about what we sell.
We especially want
- Collections from the 1990s and early 2000s (Alpha through Onslaught)
- Reserved List cards in any condition
- Sealed product, especially older boxes and Collector Boosters
- Bulk rares and mythics (500 cards or more)
- Estate collections and inherited cards
- Foreign-language vintage, especially Italian Legends and foreign black border
We do not buy
- Counterfeits, at any price
- Cards with water, fire, mold, glue, or ink damage
- Single common cards under $1
- Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, or other card games. Magic only for now.
Your other options
We are not the only way to sell a collection. Here is how the choices compare.
List them yourself on TCGplayer or eBay
Most money, most work You get close to retail prices, but you do everything: photographing, listing, pricing, packing, shipping, returns, and disputes. Platform fees take 13% or more. For a 500-card collection, plan on 30–50 hours spread over weeks.
Selling to us We do all of that work. You get one offer, one shipment, and one payment. It is less than retail, because holding and reselling the cards is how we earn our margin.
Sell to a large buylist
Fast, but low Buylists pay 50–60% of market on cards in demand and often nothing on slow sellers. They work on volume, so a beat-up 4th Edition card and a near-mint one tend to get the same offer.
Selling to us We pay 70–80% on Reserved List and good vintage cards because we sell them at retail ourselves. Condition changes our offer because it changes what the card sells for.
Take them to a local game store
Cash the same day A local store typically pays 40–55% on cards in demand and less on bulk. Cash on the spot is a real benefit. Most stores focus on current Standard and cards people are playing now.
Selling to us We pay more for vintage and Reserved List cards because that is what we specialize in. We are slower than walk-in cash, at 1–2 days, but on a good collection the difference in price is large.
Where we buy
We accept collections by mail from anywhere in the United States.
We meet in person throughout the Oklahoma City area: Oklahoma City, Norman, Edmond, Moore, Midwest City, Yukon, Mustang, Stillwater, and Shawnee. We can meet at a public place, the game store of your choice, or your home if that is easier.
There is no appraisal fee. We look at your cards for free and you decide whether to take the offer.