Rare cards, second chance.
Magic: The Gathering singles, bought and sold in Oklahoma City.
Mox Mulligan is a small, owner-operated shop. Every card is graded honestly, and the condition we list is the condition you get.
Selling your cards to us
If you have a Magic collection that has been gathering dust for years (yours, a relative's, an estate, a hobby you downsized), we are buyers. We especially want cards from the 1990s and early 2000s, Reserved List singles, sealed product, and bulk rares.
We typically pay 70–80% of TCG Mid Price for Reserved List and vintage singles. Most buylists offer 50–55%. We can pay more because we hold good cards and resell them at retail instead of flipping them for a quick margin.
Buying cards from us
The cards on our Buy cards page are graded honestly, priced against the live TCGplayer market, and sold with secure online checkout.
- Reserved List singles. Cards from the 1990s, Alpha through Urza's block.
- Pre-Modern singles. 4th Edition, Mirage block, Tempest block, Urza's block, and the early 2000s. Staples for Old School, Legacy, and Vintage Cube.
- Modern rares and mythics. Selected Modern, Pioneer, and Commander staples, graded conservatively before listing.
Grades are NM, LP, MP, or HP, with edges, surface, and centering called out where it matters.
Cards you can buy today
All cards in stockWho runs the shop
Mox Mulligan is a one-person shop, operated by a U.S. military veteran with cyber operations experience who has played Magic since 1995. It exists because cards collected for thirty years deserve buyers who appreciate them, and because every buyer deserves honest grading.
Get in touch
Email is the fastest way to reach us. We usually reply within 1–2 business days. If you are selling a collection, the Sell your cards page has the full offer and a form.